Vegan Potato & Cheese Pierogi

I don’t know much about my Polish heritage besides the fact that my great grandparents came to America from Poland in search of a new life. But what I do know is that I absolutely, positively, adore pierogi.

While the exact origin of pierogi is unclear, they are extremely popular in Poland and are even considered the national dish. They’re stuffed with all kinds of different things for various occasions, ranging from savory options like meat or potatoes, to sweet fillings like blueberries. This recipe was inspired by the “Pierogi Ruskie” which is one of the most popular styles both in Poland and in North America.

I just can’t imagine a better comfort food than a dumpling filled with cheesy mashed potatoes. I’m not going to lie, this recipe was scary to me at first. I am normally not a “from scratch” type of person. If I can buy something to make a dish easier and less labor-intensive, I do it. But, trust me when I say, store-bought pierogi don’t even come close to these homemade magical little dumplings. And while this recipe is a time-consuming process, I can promise you, it is easier than it seems, and so worth it!

If you want to cut down on some of the cooking time day-of, you can pre-make the dough and keep it in the fridge for up to 48 hours, and you can pre-make the filling as well, just both warm up a bit before making the dumplings. You also have an option to freeze these babies before boiling them.

Whatever way you decide to make these, just do it! Put on a fun spotify playlist or a great podcast and just get lost in the process. Creating this recipe was so therapeutic for me and I hope making it will be for you too.

Don’t forget to tag me on IG and Pinterest @vegantraveleats whenever you make my recipes and don’t forget to leave a rating or review below.

Vegan Potato & Cheese Pierogi

These vegan potato and cheese Polish dumplings are a labor of love but so worth it!

Course Appetizer, Dinner, Snack

Cuisine Polish-Inspired

Keyword Plant-Based Cheese Pierogi, Vegan Cheese Pierogi

Prep Time 1 15

Cook Time 45

Total Time 2

Servings pierogi

Author Valerie Libutti

Equipment

Rolling Pin
3″ cookie cutter

Ingredients

2 cups all purpose flour + a little extra for flouring the surface
¾ cup vegan sour cream
¼ cup vegan butter softened
½ tsp salt
½ lb russet potatoes
¼ cup vegan shredded cheddar cheese
1 tsp white miso
1 tsp nutritional yeast
½ tsp white vinegar or apple cider vinegar
1 ½ tbs vegan butter
1 tbs vegan milk
4-6 tbs vegan butter

Toppings of your choice!

caramelizer onion
chives
more cheese
more sour cream

Instructions

In a large bowl, combine flour and salt with a fork or whisk. Add sour cream, and butter, and work the dough. Stir to combine as best as you can and then knead with your hands for a minute. Transfer the dough to a lightly floured surface and continue to work it with your hands for a few minutes. The dough should come together and but still be a little shaggy.
Wrap the dough in a clean kitchen towel or plastic wrap and refrigerate for 30 minutes or up to 48 hours.
While the dough is resting, let’s make the filling. Peel the potatoes and cut them into 1-inch cubes. Add to a medium saucepan, cover with two inches of water and add ½ tbs salt. Bring the water to a boil over high heat then lower to a low boil and boil until potatoes are tender. At about 15 minutes start checking them with a butter knife.
Once the potatoes are tender, turn off the heat, drain them and add them back to the pot. Add oat milk and butter and mash until thoroughly mashed. Add nutritional yeast, miso, vinegar, cheddar, salt & pepper, mash to combine again and set aside.
Bring a large pot of salted water to boil while you make the dumplings.
Once the dough has been resting for long enough, pull it from the fridge and cut in half. Keep one half under a kitchen towel or rewrap in plastic wrap and roll the other half out until it’s about 1/8” thick. Use a 3” round cookie cutter or the 3″ top of a drinking glass to cut out circles of dough.
Keeping a small bowl or cup of water nearby, take a dough circle and add a heaping tsp of the mashed potato filling. Dip the tip of your finger in the water and run it along the edge of half of the circle. Fold the circle in half over the filling and pinch the ends together with your fingers to seal. Repeat until the dumplings are made and then repeat the whole process with the other half of the dough you reserved.
If you’d like to freeze the pierogi for another day, this is the time. Just use them within a month.
Otherwise, time to boil! Depending on the width of your pot opening, drop about 7-10 pierogi in at a time. Don’t overload the pot otherwise they will stick.
The pierogi will float in a couple of minutes and then cook for 1-2 minutes after that till they look nice and plump. Using a slotted spoon, transfer them to a plate and repeat until all of them are cooked.
Don’t overlap the dumplings because they will stick to each other, you’ll probably need a few plates or you can use a baking sheet.
[If you’d like caramelized onion on your pierogi, which I highly recommend, go ahead and make that now]
Once all of the pierogi are boiled, heat a large skillet over medium-high heat. Add 1 tbs butter and once melted, add 1/3 of the pierogi. Cook until browned, about 1-2 minutes, then flip and cook on the other side. Repeat until all pierogi are seared on the outside. Serve with desired toppings!